I was reading The School for Bad Girls and I mentioned how much I was enjoying it to an acquaintance. Immediately, she said, "I thought Anandibai Joshi was the first female doctor from India." We looked it up, and of course, I found myself going down a rabbit hole.When I finished reading the book, I saw author Madhurima Vidyarthi's note about the ongoing and "largely pointless" debate about who the first Indian woman to become a doctor was, and I smiled. After presenting a list of undeniable facts, the author goes on to ask,But why should that be important? The race was not against each other, but a joint struggle against society, patriarchy and bureaucracy. The School For Bad Girls, p. 303And that is what the book is all about---a struggle for something that should never have been a struggle at all, yet continues to be one.Set in nineteenth century Calcutta, The … [Read more...]
Munni Monster
I read Munni Monster a few months ago and loved it. It's a beautiful book, written with empathy and ending with hope. I knew I had to introduce it to my book club, and I can't wait to do so.Munni Monster is a book about a difficult subject, but for me, dwelling on only the subject matter of the book as we read is a bit of an overkill. The children will, I know, understand the messages the book conveys without any interference on my part. Of course, we will talk about cerebral palsy, but that cannot be the only thing we discuss without ruining the beauty of the book, so here's what we will do as we read. Secret Hiding Places Mishti has her own little hidey-hole that no one else is allowed to enter.Do you have a private place of your own? I know I did, as a child. I made my own hiding places too, with umbrellas in a corner, or saris under a dining … [Read more...]
Munni Monster
Mishti's life is good. She has a best friend (never mind if said best friend is a little annoying), parents who love her, and a grandmother whom she adores. Everything's perfect--until Munni, her grandmother's cousin, comes to stay--no, live--with them. And suddenly, things are not idyllic anymore. Munni is a weirdo. She is old, but behaves like a baby. She dares to come into Munni's private cave under the dining table. And Mishti has to sleep like a sausage between her parents even though she is "of age", to use a phrase she's just learnt.And that is the crux of the story. Munni is a monster, and Mishti must figure out how to get rid of her. She wishes Munni were dead.Munni Monster is a lovely book, empathetic and heartwarming. It worked for me so much better than Madhurima Vidyarthi's My Grandmother's Masterpiece. Cuteness in children's stories is not something I enjoy, and … [Read more...]
My Grandmother’s Masterpiece
So often, we think of our grandparents simply as grandparents. We are the centre of the universe after all, aren't we?But Nini discovers that there is more to her grandmother than just being a grandmother. A stray conversation leads her to ask her mother to buy a box of paints for her grandmother, her Minima. And then, a journey of discovery begins - for Nini, her grandmother and the entire family.My Grandmother's Masterpiece is a lovely story that celebrates the relationship between grandparent and grandchild, but it's more than that. It's the story of Nini's Minima who is suddenly free to do everything she wants to do all because her granddaughter got her a box of paints. Here's what we'll do with the book at my reading programme. Pictionary There's one section in th book where Nini asks her Minima if she is drawing bhoots. Minima shakes her head and … [Read more...]